Having Drinks with Mom or Dad?
January 30th, 2012 Posted in Criminal IssuesWhile some Ohio University students and their parent(s) eagerly await the opportunity to share the bonding ritual of having a few drinks together in a college bar, it is unfortunate that Mom’s and Dad’s Weekends are ruined for some families when the underage student is later arrested by the police for being under the influence of alcohol. Ultimately, this situation usually occurs when the parent has left the bar and/or gone home early and the student is no longer under “parental supervision”. There are three elements to the charge of underage drinking: possession, consumption and being under the influence in a public place. Any of these components by themselves or any combination thereof can result in a citation and/or arrest by the police. Even though Ohio law allows the student to avoid the consequences of being charged with underage possession or consumption of alcohol when the parent purchases the drinks, the student still faces the danger of being charged with “being under the influence” of alcohol in a public place when a parent is absent. Here is an example from a previous Dad’s weekend:
A student and her father were drinking together at one of the uptown bars. The student had consumed a “few” drinks, but she says she did not drink enough to be obviously impaired. The dad and daughter parted ways when he went home and the student and her friend walked to their residence hall. During their walk, the student allegedly made a rude gesture at a passing car, prompting a nearby police officer to approach and ask her if she had been drinking. The student admitted her age and that she had consumed alcohol with her father. She was cited with underage because she was believed to be intoxicated in a public place and not under the supervision of her parent.
Fortunately, the Athens City Prosecutors will usually dismiss such cases where it can be proven that the parent did purchase the alcohol and consume it with the student, but the student has to pay the court costs ($104.00) to have the case dismissed.
If you have been drinking with a parent and are later stopped by police after you’ve gone your separate ways, make it known to the police officer right away that your parent provided the alcohol.
In any other case, you must remember your legal rights when approached by the police. Under the Fifth Amendment, it is well within a citizen’s right to refuse to answer questions when approached by police. You can simply say, “My name is Jane Smith and I live at 123 Any Street (give your REAL name and address, of course!). I do not want to answer any more questions without my attorney present”. This can further protect you from being convicted if you are arrested. If you readily admit that you are under 21 and you have been drinking, it just gives the police more evidence to convict you. Not incriminating yourself can only help you in the long run. See our flier: “Survival Tips for Court Street” for additional practical advice.
Patrick McGee, Managing Attorney
Heidi Sochia, Program Coordinator